Union Budget · a data story

Did the government get it right?

Every year, the Union Budget prints what it plans to collect from each tax - and two years later, prints what actually came in. Lined up since 1997-98, that turns into a scorecard of the government's own forecasting.

How far off, every year since 1997-98

Each line is one tax: how much more (above zero) or less (below zero) actually came in than was originally budgeted, as a percentage of the original budgeted figure.

Total Tax Revenue Corporation Tax Customs Excise Duty

Zero means the government's original guess was exactly right. A gap in a line is a year that specific figure isn't available (see Method, below).

The COVID year no one budgeted for

In February 2020, the government budgeted ₹24.6 lakh cr in total tax revenue for 2019-20. What actually came in was -18.3% less - a corporate tax rate cut that September and a slowing economy, months before the pandemic even began. The following year, budgeted before COVID-19 reached India, missed by -16.3%.

Corporation Tax alone swung from -27.3% in 2019-20 to -32.8% in 2020-21 - then overshot by +30.2% in 2021-22, as profits rebounded faster than anyone had budgeted for.

-18.3%
Total Tax Revenue vs. Budget, 2019-20
-16.3%
Total Tax Revenue vs. Budget, 2020-21
+30.2%
Corporation Tax vs. Budget, 2021-22
-1.1%
Total Tax Revenue vs. Budget, 2024-2025

Outside a crisis, the misses are modest

Set the two COVID years aside, and the government's own Budget Estimate for Total Tax Revenue has typically landed within about ±10% of what was actually collected - a genuinely narrow band for a forecast made a year in advance, across a $3+ trillion economy.

Method

Every figure above is computed live from orf_data_labs.budget_main_line - the 59,301-row table built by parsing 27 years of the Union Budget's own Annual Financial Statement (real PDF text, OCR where a PDF had none, and 1997-98's original HTML pages). See etl/budget/README.md for how that table was built and verified, checkpoint by checkpoint.

Before this page is shown, 6 figures below are recomputed and checked against values read directly off the warehouse table by hand. If any of them no longer match, this page keeps showing its last good numbers rather than something wrong.

CheckedComputed hereExpected
Corporation Tax, budgeted for 2019-20 766000 766000 ✓ match
Corporation Tax, actual for 2019-20 556875.55 556875.55 ✓ match
Corporation Tax, actual for 2021-22 712037.33 712037.33 ✓ match
Total Tax Revenue, actual for 2020-21 2027103.84 2027103.84 ✓ match
Customs, actual for 1997-98 40192.78 40192.78 ✓ match
Union Excise Duties, actual for 2023-24 305362.18 305362.18 ✓ match